nichtrueckkehrtage-grenzgaenger-schweiz

Germany–Switzerland · Article 15a

Non-return days for cross-border commuters between Germany and Switzerland

Cross-border commuter status under Article 15a of the Germany–Switzerland tax treaty requires separate consideration of regular returns home and work-related non-return days. Since 2026, regular return generally requires travel from home to the workplace and back on at least 20% of the contractually agreed working days in the calendar year. In addition, a limit of generally 60 work-related non-return days applies to full-time employment throughout the year. Failure to meet either requirement can substantially change the tax treatment of employment income.

Updated: 3 November 2026 · Rules applicable from 2026

Article 15a(2) of the tax treaty

Regular return and non-return days must be assessed separately

A cross-border commuter, or Grenzgänger, is generally a person resident in one contracting state who has their workplace in the other contracting state and regularly returns home from that workplace.

The treaty does not require a return home every single working day. However, since 1 January 2026, paragraph 5(b) of the Protocol specifies the regular-return requirement: the employee must generally travel from home to the workplace and back on at least 20% of the working days agreed under their employment contract or contracts for the calendar year.

Separately, cross-border commuter status is lost if the applicable number of work-related non-return days is exceeded. For full-time employment throughout the year, up to 60 such days are generally permitted. Not every night spent away from the German home counts as a non-return day.

Regular return from 2026

At least 20% of the agreed working days must involve commuting to work and back

The relevant denominator is the number of contractually agreed working days in the calendar year. The requirement generally concerns actual journeys from home to the workplace in the other contracting state and back. Merely attending the Swiss office without the corresponding return journey is not sufficient. The percentage relates to working days, not working hours.

20%

Document regular returns home

Keep clear records of the agreed working days and actual journeys to the workplace and back. Full days worked at home are not commuting days.

60

Check non-return days separately

Even where the 20% requirement is met, the applicable limit on work-related non-return days must not be exceeded. Conversely, staying within that limit does not establish regular return.

Special provisions for work that extends over several days for operational reasons, particularly shift work and on-call duties, require separate consideration. Tax years before 2026 must be assessed under the rules applicable at that time.

The non-return-day limit

Generally 60 non-return days for full-time employment throughout the year

60 generally permitted non-return days

For full-time employment in the other contracting state throughout the calendar year, up to 60 work-related non-return days are generally permitted. Adjusted limits apply to part-year employment and part-time employment on fewer working days.

Exceeding the applicable limit results in the loss of cross-border commuter status on account of the non-return days. The regular-return requirement and the other conditions of Article 15a must also be satisfied independently.

Definition

What counts as a relevant non-return day?

A non-return day generally requires the employee actually to remain away from home after finishing work, with the non-return caused by their work. An express exception applies from 2026 to one-day business trips to third countries: these count as non-return days even if the employee returns home.

JOB

A work-related reason

The non-return must be connected with the performance of the employee’s work. Typical situations may include business trips lasting several days, work-related overnight stays and particular work assignments.

NIGHT

Actual non-return

An employee relying on the unreasonableness of the return journey must actually have remained away from home. One-day business trips to third countries are subject to the special treaty counting rule.

DAY

A working day

The starting point is generally the working days agreed in the employment contract or, if there is no such agreement, the actual working days. Annual leave and sickness absences are not working days for the non-return-day assessment. Special rules apply to business trips and employer-required work on otherwise non-working days.

Key distinction

Private overnight stays generally do not count as work-related non-return days

If a cross-border commuter stays away from their German home for private reasons, the necessary connection with their work is generally absent.

Accordingly, not every night away from the German home should be added to the non-return-day record. However, private overnight stays also do not replace actual commuting journeys for the separate regular-return assessment.

  • record work-related overnight stays separately
  • distinguish private stays
  • document business trips
  • record the workplace for each day
  • document where each night was spent
  • record the reason for not returning home

Work-related reasons

A non-return day may arise where returning home after work would be unreasonable

Under paragraph 5(e) of the Protocol, work-related non-return may arise in particular where returning home is impossible or unreasonable for work-related reasons. The means of transport predominantly used determines which of the following distance and travel-time criteria is relevant.

When travelling by car, a return journey is considered unreasonable in particular where the shortest one-way road distance exceeds 100 kilometres.

When using public transport, returning home may be unreasonable in particular where the fastest one-way connection at normal commuting times takes more than 1.5 hours.

Distance & travel time

Assessing whether a daily return journey is reasonable

>100 km

Travelling by car

Where the shortest one-way road distance exceeds 100 kilometres, returning home after work may in particular be considered unreasonable.

>1.5 h

Public transport

If the fastest one-way connection at normal commuting times takes more than 1.5 hours, this may likewise indicate that returning home would be unreasonable.

Shift work & on-call duties

Work extending over several days does not automatically prevent cross-border commuter status

Shift work, hospital work, on-call duties and similar employment arrangements may involve work extending over several calendar days for operational reasons.

Under paragraph 5(c) of the Protocol, this type of work organisation does not, by itself, prevent regular return. Short interruptions lasting less than four hours are not treated as the end of work. A shift continuing beyond midnight therefore does not create a non-return day merely because the calendar date changes.

In these situations, accurate records of shift start and end times, workplaces and overnight stays are particularly important.

Working from home

A full working day at home in Germany is not a non-return day

If a cross-border commuter resident in Germany spends the entire working day at their German home, this is not a day on which they fail to return home after work because of their work.

Full working days at home therefore generally do not count as non-return days. However, they are also not commuting days for the 20% assessment. A high proportion of working from home can consequently mean that the regular-return requirement is not met, even though the non-return-day limit is observed.

  • a full working day at the German home is not a non-return day
  • check the 20% requirement separately
  • record home-working days separately from Swiss working days
  • assess the tax consequences
  • assess social security separately
  • count commuting journeys and non-return days separately

Part-year employment

The full 60-day limit does not automatically apply when employment starts or ends during the year

If an employee is not employed in the other contracting state throughout the calendar year, the permitted number of non-return days is reduced proportionately.

Generally, five days are allowed for each full month of employment and one day for each additional full week of employment not already included in those full months.

The resulting individual limit is the relevant threshold for the employment period concerned.

Employment arrangement General rule Effect
Full-time employment throughout the year 60 days Up to 60 relevant non-return days are permitted, provided regular return and the other requirements are satisfied.
Full months of employment 5 days per full month Reduce the individual annual limit accordingly.
Additional full weeks 1 day per full week Additional allowance when calculating the part-year limit.
Part-time work on every normal working day Generally 60 days Reducing daily working hours does not automatically reduce the 60-day limit.
Part-time work on selected weekdays only Proportionate reduction The permitted number of days is reduced in proportion to the number of working days.

Part-time employment

Not every part-time arrangement reduces the limit below 60 days

If an employee works part-time throughout the year by working fewer hours on every normal working day, the allowance generally remains 60 non-return days. The separate regular-return requirement must still be assessed.

The position differs where part-time employment involves fewer working days, for example three agreed working days per week compared with the employer’s normal five-day full-time week. A full-time position involving three Swiss office days and two German home-working days is not this type of part-time employment.

For part-time employment on fewer working days, paragraph 5(i) of the Protocol reduces the non-return-day limit according to the ratio of contractually agreed working days to the employer’s normal full-time working days. Working from home alone does not trigger this part-time reduction.

Documentation

Keep non-return-day records throughout the year

Record working days

For each relevant day, record whether and where work was performed and whether a journey from home to the Swiss workplace and back took place. The agreed working days and home-working arrangement should also be documented.

Document overnight locations

Where the employee does not return home, record where the night was actually spent.

Identify the work-related reason

Clearly identify the business trip, on-call duty, multi-day assignment or other work-related reason.

Retain supporting evidence

Expense claims, hotel invoices, assignment schedules, calendars and employer records can substantiate the non-return days.

Prepare an itemised schedule

Where non-return days affect cross-border commuter status, a clear itemised schedule of travel days is particularly important.

Reconcile the employer’s certificate

Where cross-border commuter status is lost, reconcile the employer’s certificate of non-return days with the tax records.

Supporting evidence

Typical records for the commuting percentage and non-return days

CAL

Calendar

Record working days, commuting journeys, home-working days, annual leave, business trips and overnight stays promptly, and reconcile them with the employment contract.

HOTEL

Hotel invoices

Hotel invoices can document work-related overnight stays away from the German home.

TRIP

Travel expense claims

Employer travel expense records can substantiate the work-related reason for not returning home.

SHIFT

Duty and shift schedules

For shift work and on-call duties, schedules provide important evidence of working hours and work arrangements.

GRE

Cross-border commuter forms

The certificate of residence and, where applicable, the employer’s certificate should be consistent with the other tax records.

LIST

Travel-day schedule

An itemised schedule showing the date, workplace, overnight location and reason for non-return makes the assessment considerably easier.

Limit exceeded

Exceeding the applicable limit changes the tax classification

If the employee’s applicable limit is exceeded, cross-border commuter status under Article 15a is generally lost for the tax year concerned.

Employment income must then generally be assessed under Article 15, subject to any applicable special provisions. The country where the work is performed and the actual working days may consequently determine how employment income is allocated. This also generally applies where Article 15a is already unavailable because the regular-return requirement is not met.

  • stop applying the special Article 15a commuter rules
  • assess the general employment income rules under Article 15
  • allocate working days by country
  • reassess Swiss taxation
  • adjust the German tax return
  • coordinate withholding tax and tax credits

Why the limit matters

Where the limit is 60 days, the 61st relevant day is decisive

The 60-day rule does not merely change the taxation of individual days above the threshold. Exceeding the applicable limit can instead remove cross-border commuter status for the entire tax year concerned.

Employees with a large number of work-related overnight stays should therefore not wait until after the end of the year to check whether the commuter rules remain applicable.

If the limit is likely to be approached, it may be useful to model the expected German and Swiss tax treatment during the year.

Typical situations

Which days usually require closer examination?

Situation Non-return day? Points to consider
Work-related overnight stay in Switzerland Possibly Document the work-related reason and actual non-return.
Business trip lasting several days Possibly Document working days and the individual stages of the trip.
One-day business trip to a third country Yes, under the rules applicable from 2026 Also counts if the employee subsequently returns home; paragraph 5(f) of the Protocol. A third country means a country other than Germany or Switzerland.
One-day business trip within Germany or Switzerland No The third-country rule does not apply to one-day business trips in the state of residence or the state of the workplace.
Private overnight stay with friends Generally no The required connection with the employee’s work is generally absent.
Full working day at the German home No Not a non-return day, but also not a commuting day for the 20% assessment.
Long return journey and an actual overnight stay away Possibly Assess whether returning would be unreasonable and whether non-return actually occurred.
Holiday in Switzerland Generally no Not a work-related non-return on a working day.
Overnight on-call duty Not merely because the calendar date changes Assess work extending over several days for operational reasons and the actual end of work under paragraph 5(c) of the Protocol.

Common mistakes

Frequent errors when counting non-return days

01

Counting every night in Switzerland

Private overnight stays are not automatically work-related non-return days.

02

Treating working from home as non-return

Working the entire day at the German home is not a failure to return home after work.

03

Always assuming a 60-day limit

A lower individual limit may apply to part-year employment or part-time employment on fewer working days.

04

Failing to retain evidence

A retrospective list without supporting travel records and employer documentation may create evidential difficulties.

05

Looking only at overnight stays

Simply counting nights away is not sufficient. In particular, under the rules applicable from 2026, one-day business trips to third countries count as non-return days even without an overnight stay away.

06

Noticing the excess only when preparing the tax return

Swiss withholding tax and the German tax assessment may consequently already have been based on an incorrect tax assumption during the year.

Frequently asked questions

Non-return days for cross-border commuters working in Switzerland

What does the 20% rule mean from 2026?
Regular return generally requires actual journeys from home to the workplace and back on at least 20% of the contractually agreed working days in the calendar year. The applicable non-return-day limit must also be observed.
Can cross-border commuter status be unavailable without any non-return days?
Yes. If the 20% requirement is not met, for example because the employee works almost exclusively at their German home, regular return may be absent. Zero work-related non-return days therefore do not guarantee cross-border commuter status.
What is a non-return day for a cross-border commuter?
Generally, it is a day on which an employee actually fails to return home after work for work-related reasons. Since 2026, one-day business trips to third countries also count as non-return days even where the employee returns home.
How many non-return days are permitted?
For full-time employment throughout the year, up to 60 relevant non-return days are generally permitted. The limit must be reduced for part-year employment or part-time employment on fewer working days. Regular return and the other conditions for cross-border commuter status must also be satisfied.
What happens on the 61st non-return day?
If the individual limit is 60 days, exceeding it generally removes cross-border commuter status for the tax year concerned. Where a lower individual limit applies, status may be lost sooner. Article 15 and any applicable special treaty provisions must then generally be assessed.
Does a private overnight stay in Switzerland count as a non-return day?
Generally, not merely because it is an overnight stay. For the 60-day rule, non-return must result from the employee’s work. Private reasons must therefore be distinguished from work-related reasons.
Does a working day at home in Germany count as a non-return day?
No. A working day spent entirely at home is not a non-return day. However, it is also not a commuting day for the 20% assessment. A high proportion of working from home may therefore prevent cross-border commuter status even where the non-return-day limit is observed.
When is a daily return journey considered unreasonable?
The means of transport predominantly used is decisive. For a car, the shortest one-way road distance exceeding 100 kilometres is particularly relevant. For public transport, the relevant criterion is the shortest one-way journey taking more than 1.5 hours at normal commuting times. A non-return day based on these circumstances requires the employee actually to have remained away from home.
How is the limit calculated when employment starts during the year?
For part-year employment, the limit is reduced proportionately. Generally, five permitted non-return days are allowed for each full month of employment and one day for each additional full week not already included in those full months.
Is the 60-day limit always reduced for part-time employment?
No. Where an employee works fewer hours on every normal working day throughout the year, the limit generally remains 60 days. Where part-time employment involves fewer working days, the limit is reduced according to the ratio of agreed working days to normal full-time working days. Working from home without changing the number of agreed working days is not part-time employment on fewer days.
Which records should I keep for non-return days?
Useful records include calendars and working-day schedules, hotel invoices, travel expense claims, business travel documentation, shift schedules and an itemised list showing dates, workplaces, overnight locations and work-related reasons.
How does taxation change if cross-border commuter status is lost?
Employment income is generally no longer taxed under the special cross-border commuter provisions of Article 15a. Instead, the general rules under Article 15 are particularly relevant. Actual working days in Germany, Switzerland and any third countries may then determine the allocation of taxing rights.

Germany–Switzerland tax advice

Approaching the 60-day limit or unsure which days count?

We assess regular return, including the 20% requirement, your individual non-return-day limit, home-working and business travel days, and the consequences of a potential loss of cross-border commuter status. We coordinate the German and Swiss tax treatment.

Arrange an initial consultation